Furthermore, we assert that the open source software communitys social structure demands benevolent leadership. If youre building software to solve a human problem, you need to talk to those humans. It is a form of software piracyusing without paying. Oct 15, 2019 moreover, many would assert myself included that the real value of ethical oss licenses is that they are inherently disruptive by bringing attention to these ethical issues, challenging the status quo including the open source definition, and spreading the idea in jensons words that software should be used for the betterment of the. Unavoidable ethical questions about open source markkula. My goal was to spark conversation about the implications of the. While the term is commonly used to refer to opensource software code, it can refer to the open access to any products design. Times new roman arial ribbons ethical issues in the open source movement what is oss solution to forced upgrades back to the good old days many hands light work free softwareopen source an article i recommend many of the contributions of the free software community are admirable. Why open source misses the point of free software gnu. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source software by daliah saper saper law offices, llc 505 n. But in majority, students didnt put much attention toward software piracy issues.
Open source licences can be a source of some confusion. Weve seen above that if you exercise a little judgment in picking through your alternatives, you will generally find. Most open source software has greater customization, meaning that the software can be tailored to fit ones personal or. There are three major issues in using or reusing open source software. In this essay we argue that the current social and ethical structure in the open source software oss community stem from its roots in academia. Perspectives on environmental issues, engaged activism, philosophy, arts and ethical living aeon. This is why i believe open source software is the most ethical choice. If you can choose between a proprietary software w, and free opensource software l, then the choice is yours to make. Much of this discussion centres around the use of the word free. Open source code is common, potentially dangerous, in enterprise apps look into vendors software supply chain, check the maturity of their software lifecycle programs. Dec 11, 2012 open source software refers to any software subjected to a license that makes the source code available to everyone. Find out more about this topic, read articles and blogs or research legal issues, cases, and codes on. We at the software freedom law center are extremely fortunate because we get to provide legal assistance to some of the worlds leading free and open source software foss projects. Open source licences give you free access to the source code of an application, and the ability to edit, modify and share this code without seeking special.
The ethics of free software chair of software engineering. Pdf ethical interest in free and open source software. Ethical issues with the software piracy issue free essays. Are there ethical considerations for using open source software. Yesterday, i wrote a bit about my struggles with the ethics of the tools we use. Feb 16, 2017 the idea behind opensource access to what would otherwise potentially be considered proprietary information is one that has risen in importance with the expansion of the use of the web. This document gives an overview of some common issues in open source licensing and license compatibility. Finally, we argue that open source software introduces ethical challenges for universities and the software development community. Four reasons you dont want to use open source software. The ways in which all open source1 licenses are the same are greater than the ways in which they differ but their differences can still be significant.
If you can choose between a proprietary software w, and free open source software l, then the choice is yours to make. The views expressed are those of the author, not necessarily those of the magazines editors or sponsors. Aug 20, 2018 amazon and microsoft also are grappling with similar issues about what constitutes ethical use of their ai technologies. This resource is based on the approaches to ethics outlined in the markkula center for applied ethics framework for ethical decision making. The main initial motivation of those who split off the open source camp from the free software movement was that the ethical ideas of free software made some people uneasy. An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open. The individual developers experience a level of autonomy similar to that of a faculty member.
He was the first person to help me realize that choosing open source software wasnt just good for your security it was also the most ethical. By contrast, the philosophy of open source considers issues in terms of how to make software betterin a. The idea behind open source access to what would otherwise potentially be considered proprietary information is one that has risen in importance with the expansion of the use of the web. There are some convincing reasons for why open source is helpful in an educational context. According to nousiainen, other ethical issues in the open source community include using code for profitable reasons without contributing in return. Why open source software isnt as ethical as you think it is. So is there a significant moral or ethical reason why software should be open source. Jan 27, 20 this is why i believe open source software is the most ethical choice. The growth of free software has indeed been remarkable in the past few years. The legal issues around open data and open hardware have a lot in common with the legal issues around open software. Pdf ethical issues in open source software semantic scholar. A good example of oss is drupal in all its forms, including drupal mobile.
Issues confronting the free software movement include how best to promote innovation and the common good. As software takes over more of our lives, the ethical ramifications of decisions made by programmers only become greater. There are two articles that i read that pertain to open source, one is ethical issues in open source software by frances s, grodzinsky, keith miller, and marty wolf. The mere use of the software is a step in the right direction. Jul 31, 2012 the use of open source software oss by businesses in their software applications is becoming increasingly common, learn why it is essential to check the specific terms of any oss licence. Is it ethical to use proprietary closedsource software.
By understanding the opensource communitys code of conduct and implementing best ethical practices throughout the entire project, ethical considerations wont be compromised in the name. Refutations of the ethical arguments for open source. Open source ethics article about open source ethics by the. Even among the proponents of free and open source software the definition of these terms is a constant source of controversy. We at the software freedom law center are extremely fortunate because we get to provide legal assistance to some of the. The association for computing machinery, or acm, claims to be the worlds largest educational and scientific computing society. Introduction open source software oss and the emergence of an entire open source movement have practical, political, economic and ethical ramifications for software development and software use. The use of opensource software is increasing and not just from unsanctioned installations on company equipment more organizations are adopting opensource alternatives to commercial software, even at a local government level. Pdf ethical issues in open source software researchgate. Moreover, many would assert myself included that the real value of ethical oss licenses is that they are inherently disruptive by bringing attention to these ethical issues, challenging the status quo including the open source definition, and spreading the idea in jensons words that software should be used for the betterment of the.
The state of open data and open hardware licensing. Open source and proprietary software ethical, legal. I need to write a paper on the ethical issues involving open source for a college class. Open source software oss one of the central tenants of open source. Bertrand meyer challenges some open source assumptions.
A legal issues primer for open source and free software. Software is considered ethical open source eos when it meets all of these criteria it benefits the commons. These organizations see this as a means of reducing staff layoffs or costs associated with upgrading or renewing licenses. One of the most visible results has been the linux operating system, developed under the leadership of. Times new roman arial ribbons ethical issues in the open source movement what is oss solution to forced upgrades back to the good old days many hands light work free softwareopen source an article i recommend many of the contributions of the. Finally, we argue that open source software introduces ethical challenges for. This shouldnt be surprising, because some of the technological and economic foundations are the same. Opensource software, on the other hand, mirrors typical medical research practice by reusing proven code and promoting transparency with equivalent benefits of patient safety. By contrast, sustainability issues plague many opensource software projects. Ethical issues in open source software semantic scholar. Amazon and microsoft also are grappling with similar issues about what constitutes ethical use of their ai technologies. It costs nothing and provides the source code so that anyone can modify the software for their own purposes. Introductionmuch of this paper is based on the article the defenders of free software by ashlee vance. In general, there is no difference among those levels.
An introduction to the legal issues surrounding open source. Is having your software available to anyone a security risk. Open source software, on the other hand, mirrors typical medical research practice by reusing proven code and promoting transparency with equivalent benefits of patient safety. In this article we examine ethical issues that have been raised by open source software and its challenge.
If your methods are well documented, your peers can either reproduce them in w if they have it, or recreate an algorithm in software l this happens a lot. Investment and business issues are certainly the major drawbacks to the creation of opensource software. The five principles of software ethics the new stack. Is it ethical to use proprietary closedsource software for. Bertrand meyer challenges some opensource assumptions. Weve compiled an open list of resources for ethical living from browsers to books, ted talks to apps.
We argue that it is difficult to pass off low quality open source software as high quality software and that the open source development model offers strong accountability. Ethical issues in open source software by frances grodzinsky. The articletalks about how many major corporations are using open source software, but, they are not fulfillingtheir end of the open source agreement. From a utilitarian perspective questions about the greatest good visavis open source software mirror larger discussions about intellectual property protection. Weve seen above that if you exercise a little judgment in picking through your alternatives, you will generally find one or more of quite respectable quality. Here are several articles from both sides of this debate. There are some benefits of using w and some of using l. Investment and business issues are certainly the major drawbacks to the creation of open source software. The use of open source software oss by businesses in their software applications is becoming increasingly common, learn why it is essential to check the specific terms of any oss licence. Open source ethics article about open source ethics by.
Any person wishing to join the society must accept a code of ethics and professional conduct, which covers the ethical issues surrounding software piracy. The idea behind opensource access to what would otherwise potentially be considered proprietary information is one that has risen in importance with the expansion of the use of the web. Open source software has captured public attention during the past few years for its distinctive approach to software licensing and communitybased programming, as well as the growing market share of programs developed under the open source model. Most open source licenses allow the software to be redistributed without restriction under the same terms of the license. Purisms librem 5 is built for security by design and run on opensource software. Those who have laptops may prefer using unlicensed operating system than using open source operating system. The tragedy of having free, useful code is that the maintainers often dont have the resources to support themselves long term. While the term is commonly used to refer to open source software code, it can refer to the open access to any products design. Ethical issues in open source software article pdf available in journal of information communication and ethics in society 14. In my last post, i briefly mentioned that there is an ethical discussion in the software community about the relationship between ethics and free software. For the free software movement, free software is an ethical imperative, essential respect for the users freedom. Ethical issues in open source software emerald insight.
This is the original text of the article entitled the ethics of free software printed in the march 2000 issue, unabridged and unedited. I do not expect everyone who uses open source software to understand what is going on at a technical level, or submit bug reports or patches. You can change the source code or even change its mode of operation. There are three major issues in using or reusing opensource software.
The crux of this ethical discussion is the relationship between software and civil liberties. Not all open source software is distributed under the same type of licensing agreement. Open source code is common, potentially dangerous, in. The license under which the software is released must not prohibit modification, derivative works, and linking or compiling with other software unless under a copyleft provision, in the general spirit of open source distribution.
452 29 221 670 955 1055 981 960 101 865 538 277 1016 1586 138 1315 925 729 587 428 175 1211 1347 728 706 217 1123 1314 946 1147 204 373 710 1253 9 143 1049 1232 1277 219